The Value of Observing Structure

Observing structure is a lost art in much Bible study. We fixate on a few verses, and we fail to look for larger literary patterns in larger portions of text. But most Bible books would have been read orally, and authors used larger literary patterns to help people retain information. Public speakers do the same thing today when they repeat and reiterate and reinforce their points through rhythmic patterns of variation. (Just think of Martin Luther King, Jr.’s famous “I have a dream” speech.)

In his wonderful book, The Literary Structure of the Old Testament, David A. Dorsey enumerates 10 benefits gained by observing structure:

1. Appreciation of literary artistry

Les Haines (2012), Creative Commons

God’s word is not simply true; it is also beautiful, just like he is.

2. Identification of unit boundaries

Knowing the structure might help you break up the passage sensibly for your Bible study or sermon series.

3. Discovery of the rationale behind a unit’s overall layout

When you can’t figure out why events are in such a strange order, perhaps the author arranged them purposefully to make a certain point.

4. Clarification of the relationship of the parts to the whole

Tracking structure will help you to keep the smaller episodes or stanzas connected to the main point of the whole book.

5. Accounting for repetitions

For example, why does Genesis 6-9 keep repeating the names of Noah’s sons (Gen 6:10, 7:13, 9:18)? They serve as markers for the structure.

• The world is bad (sons named)
  • God gives Noah instructions
    • A sampling of all living things (sons named) get on the ark
      • Waters rise
        • God remembers the ark’s inhabitants
      • Waters fall
    • The living things (including the sons, unnamed this time) get off the ark
  • God gives Noah instructions
• The world is still bad (sons named)

6. Accounting for apparently misplaced units

Some scholars don’t know what to do with passages like Genesis 38 or Nehemiah 5 or Isaiah 36-39 that seem to be completely misplaced (way out of order) within their books. But these placements make more sense when we consider the outlines of those books.

7. Clarification of a unit by comparison with its match

For example, Jonah’s prayer in Jonah 2 appears pious and repentant until you consider the parallel prayer in chapter 4. Suddenly his repentance doesn’t look very repentant.

8. A check on redaction-critical theories

For a hundred and fifty years or so, unbelieving scholars spent their time picking apart books of the Bible and showing how all the parts couldn’t have been written by the same person. However, this approach isn’t so common anymore, as the unity and beauty (see point #1 above) of each book speaks a more compelling truth.

9. Discovery of a unit’s main point

Here is something truly worth getting pumped up for. Sometimes a passage’s main point is more implicit than explicit, and the author tucks that point right into his shaping of the composition.

10. Discovery of a composition’s theme

A theme is an idea woven into the fabric of a book. That theme might not be clear until you’ve seen it crop up in many sections. Observing structure brings themes into the foreground.

So much for the principles. To see them in action, look at how much difference structure makes in each gospel’s telling of the feeding of the 5,000. Through the context and structure of each Gospel, we see that Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John can use the same event for a different purpose.

————————–

Disclosure: The Amazon link above is an affiliate link, so if you click it and buy stuff you’ll support this site at no extra cost to yourself.